The author of When Discourses Collide is Jason Palmeri, who is currently an associate professor of English at Miami University. This text is from the Journal of Business Communication so I’d say that the primary audience is most likely high level academics. This text implies that rhetoric is writing with a purpose. That purpose being either to provide facts or to persuade someone. This text implies that genre is similar to Bitzer’s example of the rhetorical context a person is writing in. The main argument of the text is that the difference in discourse communities (i.e rhetoric) between nurse consultants and attorneys can lead to misunderstandings due to different writing expectations in both fields. The text describes the importance of rhetoric in other fields like law and medicine by highlighting the importance of writers because they know how to adapt different works of rhetoric to fit the audience and context of what genre they are writing in.
I really liked your analysis of Palmeri because it answered all the questions quickly and, what I think, accurately. I find it tough to find the definitions of rhetoric and genre in these dense texts (and honestly the simple ones too) because I want so badly for the author to just say “This is my definition of…”, but thats never gonna happen. I think you were pretty accurate in your definitions and feel like I got similar vibes after re-reading the peice.
LikeLike